Home News Sport Business Innovation Culture Arts Travel Earth Audio Video Live
Register Sign In
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement by
Essential Guide to Discover the latest Robotics and Artificial What is the latest on Uncover the latest
Inheritance Tax - Free finance insights from Intelligence. Discover ETFs? trends in retirement
12 page Guide global experts. the trends. MarketViews planning strategies.
Buckingham Gate MarketViews MarketViews MarketViews
One Battle After Another: Why this
year's most acclaimed film flopped
1 hour ago Share Save
Nicholas Barber
Warner Bros Pictures
(Credit: Warner Bros Pictures)
Paul Thomas Anderson's political thriller One Battle After Another, ADVERTISEMENT
starring Leonardo DiCaprio, has been critically acclaimed and hailed as Advertisement by Taboola
a "masterpiece", but won't break even at the box office.
Paul Thomas Anderson's One Battle After Another is one of the most
acclaimed films of the year, with countless rave reviews hailing it as a
masterpiece. What's more, these reviews agree that it isn't one of those
eat-your-vegetables masterpieces that are a slog to get through, but
Nuevo Hyundai INSTER.
which give you a nice, warm, virtuous feeling when they're finished. The
critical consensus is that the film is an action-packed, wildly entertaining Hyundai España Más información
night at the cinema. "It's impossible to overstate how much fun this thing
is," says Max Weiss in Baltimore Magazine. "It's a terrific ride," concludes
Nick Bradshaw in Sight & Sound. And the BBC's Caryn James praises a
car chase "that makes you feel as if you're on a rollercoaster". Throw in the
star power of the film's lead, Leonardo DiCaprio, not to mention his co-
stars, Sean Penn and Benicio del Toro, and you've got all the makings of a
box-office smash.
Or maybe not. Last week, Variety magazine reported that several recent
films aimed at a grown-up audience had all missed their targets, among
them Roofman and The Smashing Machine. And the biggest loser of
them all? You guessed it. "Though the global haul of $140m (£105m) is
impressive for a film that's original, R rated and nearly three hours long,"
said the article, "One Battle requires roughly $300m (£224m) to break
even." The film's budget was $130m (£97m), according to its studio,
Warner Bros, although some sources calculate that it could be more than
$10m higher. With marketing costs stacked on top of that, says Variety,
One Battle After Another "is tracking to lose $100 million".
One Battle After Another - O/cial Trailer - Warner Bro…
Copiar enl…
Ver en
The article does include a statement from Warner Bros, disputing
the sums presented by Variety, but no one would argue that One Battle
After Another is making a fortune. It's now been in cinemas for four
weekends since its release in late September, and according to Box Office
Mojo, its takings add up to just $162.5m (£119m). For those of us who
would like to see a greater range of unformulaic films in cinemas, such
figures look at first to be disheartening, and even perplexing. If audiences
don't show up for a rollercoaster ride with Leo, what will they show up
for?
It's what they point at when people criticise them for not doing real
films any more – John Bleasdale
The simple answer is a gloomy one: in the post-pandemic era, when so
many films are available to stream, it does seem that nothing except IP-
based blockbusters and horror films can tempt large numbers of paying
customers into the multiplex. But that's not the whole story. From
another perspective, the One Battle After Another situation can be seen
as a cause for celebration.
"I think the film is doing phenomenally well," Charles Gant, box-office
editor at Screen International, tells the BBC, "precisely because audiences
are loving it, and word of mouth is super-positive, and the film lends itself
to the PLF [premium large format] and premium experience. It's already
earned almost double Paul Thomas Anderson's previous biggest film, and
it should go a fair bit higher."
One point to remember is that One Battle After Another is sure to have a
long shelf life. It may not do Avengers numbers, but it will make more
money in cinemas following its inevitable Oscar nominations, and, as an
acclaimed film set to endure, significant additional revenue will come
from reissues, Blu-ray sales, streaming and television. That doesn't mean
it's ever going to be a cash cow for Warner Bros, but it doesn't mean that
it's a shocking failure, either.
But the fact is that Anderson is an art house film-maker, and, as much as
critics have pushed it as an action-comedy, One Battle After Another is an
art house film. Its hectic rhythms, nerve-jangling music, deeply flawed
characters, intensely political subject matter, and eccentric mix of
seriousness and silliness mark it as the work of a writer-director who is
determined to fulfil his own creative ambitions, however uncommercial
the results. The reviews and the word of mouth may be superlative, but
it's still a challenging film for anyone in the mood for a Friday night
blockbuster.
A sound investment?
The real reason its box-office takings seem woeful is that its budget is so
astronomical. "The high production budget is making it hard to achieve
profitability – that I will concede," Gant says. Anderson's biggest film
before now was There Will Be Blood, which made $76.9m (£57m) in 2007.
At the other end of the scale, Inherent Vice – which, like One Battle After
Another, was inspired by a Thomas Pynchon novel – made just $14.5m
(£11m) in 2014. For Warner Bros, then, writing him a cheque for a much
heftier amount, even before you tot up the marketing costs, was always
going to be a major gamble. So why did they think that the gamble was
worth taking?
Some films, it seems, are valuable in ways that didn't immediately show
up on the balance sheet. "It's what [studio executives] point at when
people criticise them for not doing real films anymore," John Bleasdale,
author of The Magic Hours: The Films and Hidden Life of Terrence
Malick, tells the BBC. "And it serves to get more talent to the studio,
which is more important than money."
As much as Warner's executives must have hoped for a box-office
bonanza, it's useful for the studio to be thought of as a welcoming home
for prestigious projects by beloved auteurs. Christopher Nolan, for
instance, made films with Warner Bros for almost 20 years before he fell
out with them over the distribution of Tenet in 2020, the costly outcome
being that he switched to Universal to make Oppenheimer – and that was
one of the international success stories of 2023.
More like this:
• The film already gunning to be 2026's biggest
• Why original kids' films are flopping so badly
• Why a hunky Frankenstein's monster is all wrong
You can see why Warner was so keen to sign up Ryan Coogler, the director
of Black Panther and Creed. Coogler then made Sinners with them, which
turned out to be a box-office sensation. With that in mind, anything that
attracts more film-makers of his calibre might feel like a sound
investment. "When Terry [Malick] made Days of Heaven for Paramount,"
says Bleasdale, "Charles Bluhdorn, the president of the studio, said, 'I
don't care if we never make a dollar. I want you making movies with us.'"
You can't risk that kind of long-term strategy unless your other films are
profitable, of course, but luckily for Warner, some of 2025's biggest
money-spinners have been on the company's slate: as well as Sinners,
these include A Minecraft Movie, Final Destination: Bloodlines, F1,
Superman, Weapons, and Conjuring: The Last Rites. If One Battle After
Another hasn't been as lucrative, well, it's still enhanced Warner's
reputation as an auteur-friendly studio, forged a relationship with
Anderson, and granted them a highly respected film which will be an
awards-season favourite. Besides, as Bleasdale points out, "They get
Leonardo DiCaprio to come to their Christmas party."
Maybe One Battle After Another wasn't such a major gamble
So was the studio right to bankroll One Battle After Another?
"Considering everything else that they have had this year, it's a no-
brainer," said Lucas Shaw on a recent edition of a film industry podcast,
The Town. "You have a movie from a great contemporary film-maker
that's got good reviews, and now with Sinners you have two heavy
contenders at the Oscars. Paul Thomas Anderson [who has never won an
Academy Award] can get his Oscar, then you call it a win and decide that
your other successes have covered it. Look, if you're running a movie
studio, you have to be able to take a couple of big swings."
The whole affair echoes The Studio, Seth Rogen's Apple TV comedy
series about Hollywood executives. One episode is devoted to the studio
boss's desperation for someone to thank him on stage at the Golden
Globes – the jokey suggestion being that the film business isn't solely
about the bottom line. There's also the scene in which Catherine O'Hara's
character sums up her experience of running a studio. "The job makes you
stressed, and panicked, and miserable. But when it all comes together and
you make a good movie, it's good forever."
The Studio might see Hollywood through a rose-tinted lens, but if there
are still Hollywood executives who are willing to spend more than $130m
to make "a good movie", that's something to be pleased about. And maybe
One Battle After Another wasn't such a major gamble. If you produce a
cartoon, a superhero film or a video-game adaptation that flops – such as
Smurfs, The Flash or Borderlands – you can't console yourself by talking
about art and prestige. But if you put your money into a Paul Thomas
Anderson film then, whatever happens at the box office, you've still got a
Paul Thomas Anderson film. The chances are that you'll be proud of it. In
some ways, it's about as safe a bet as a studio executive can make.
--
If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a
handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to
your inbox twice a week.
For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us
on Facebook and Instagram.
Comment & Analysis Features
WATCH
Watch an incredible Lusotitan The quirky hen racing Is Wall Streetʼs optimism The race to unlock natureʼs Three films Aim
mating ritual championship in the UK's Peak setting up another crash? hidden secrets says will change
District
For a Lusotitan, one of the largest Katty Kay speaks to Andrew Ross A team of researchers is working on an The actress shares th
dinosaurs to have ever lived, first The Travel Show meets a flock of Sorkin about the ways that unchecked ambitious project to build the worldʼs everyone should see
impressions mattered. competitive hens battling for glory in optimism can affect an economy. largest biological database. completely shi you
Britain's first National Park.
2 hrs ago Natural wonders 2 days ago Business 3 days ago Tech Now 4 days ago Film & TV
1 day ago The Travel Show
ADVERTISEMENT
Nuevo Hyundai INSTER. Descubre KINTO, el renting El tiempo ideal para visitar
de Toyota. las soleadas islas y las
Hyundai España | Paid Content costas españolas.
KINTO España | Paid Content
Meliá Hotels | Paid Content
Una edición limitada Crmada Hyundai i20 TRS IBIZA HOTEL: Ultimate
por Manolo Valdés Ibiza Hotel Experience
Hyundai España | Paid Content
ARTIKA | Artists’ Books | Paid Content Palladium Hotel Group | Paid Content
MORE FROM THE BBC
1 hr ago
The growing costs of applying for a job
With jobs hard to find on both sides of the Atlantic, applicants are turning to paid tools to
help them secure work, but are the increased costs worth it?
1 hr ago
How a 1995 drug website became a research goldmine
In the early days of the internet, drug users flocked to a website called Erowid to detail
experiences on everything from Advil to LSD. Today it is a goldmine for researchers.
23 hrs ago
A Zen monk's guide to the best gardens in Tokyo
Shunmyo Masuno creates gardens that blend Zen philosophy with contemporary design.
Here are his favourite green spaces in Tokyo – from cherry blossom havens to historical
treasures.
1 day ago
The Dutch rewilding project that took a dark turn
In 2018, thousands of dead animals, emaciated from starvation, lay strewn across a famous
Dutch rewilding project. Was it animal cruelty or just nature taking its course?
1 day ago
Why Little Richard's Tutti Frutti was so risqué
When the single was released in 1955, it was a big hit – but only aer the original lyrics
were changed. In 1972, the singer told the BBC that "there's nothing bad" about his music.
Home News Sport Business Innovation Culture Arts Travel Earth Audio Video Live Weather BBC Shop BritBox
BBC in other languages
Follow BBC on:
Terms of Use Subscription Terms About the BBC Privacy Policy Cookies Accessibility Help Contact the BBC Advertise with us Do not share or sell my info [Link] Help & FAQs Content Index
Copyright 2025 BBC. All rights reserved. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.